Remontoir
Earthen Co. Summit
Nikolaus Hirsch: Very positiveWatchChris: Very positiveWatchTimeItIs: Very positiveDeployant: Very positiveFratello: Very positiveThe Limited Edition: Very positiveaBlogtoWatch: Positive

Each marker on the ring is one counted review, coloured by its verdict.

Earthen Co.

Summit

38mmautomatic$899 list priceAnnounced August 2025

A 38mm ceramic-cased pilot/field watch from Hong Kong brand Earthen Co., with an Arabic-numeral dial after vintage military pilot's watches and an oversized crown meant for use with gloves. It launched in three colourways (Overcast in black ceramic; Whiteout and Blue Bird in white) with a Miyota 9039 automatic and 100m water resistance.

Earthen Co. product page

Creator Consensus

Creator Consensus

Very positive

7 reviews: 7 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative. 7 of 7 recommend it.

Every reviewer rates the dial and the value positively, and nearly all single out the ceramic case as something rarely offered for the money. Several praise the legible pilot-style dial, the oversized crown, comfort across a wide range of wrists and its ease as an everyday watch. The movement draws the most reservations.

Where they differ. The movement divides opinion: some credit the Miyota calibre as robust and easy to service, while a couple find its rotor noticeably audible. One reviewer also cautions that the ceramic case can shatter on impact.

Most praised

  • Ceramic case rarely offered at this price6 of 7
    • Deployant Notes no other automatic ceramic watches seem available at this price.there do not appear to be any other automatic ceramic watches availableRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Praises bringing a full ceramic case experience to an approachable price.an impressively approachable sub-$1,000 price pointRead it in context
    • Fratello Calls a ceramic watch with this finishing at $899 quite a deal.a ceramic watch with this level of finishing for that kind of money is quite a dealRead it in context
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Calls the price a very good value proposition given ceramic cases usually cost far more.This is a very good value propositionWatch from 3:18
    • WatchTimeItIs Considers a ceramic watch under €1,000 a competitive, good price.That is competitive and that's a good price.Watch from 2:22
    • WatchChris Argues it undercuts even used ceramic watches from major brands.costs less than the competition for this watch on the used marketWatch from 6:41
    • aBlogtoWatch Sees the true ceramic case as rare in the entry-level market.the market for entry-level true ceramic watches is remarkably thinRead it in context
    • WatchChris Notes it is the first sub-$1,000 microbrand ceramic watch featured on the channel, calling that significant.That is significant because I'm not sure if this is going toWatch from 1:25
  • Quality and presentation exceed the price5 of 7
    • Deployant Finds the finishing level impressive for the price point.At this price point, the level of finishing is impressiveRead it in context
    • Deployant Concludes it is affordable, well made and beautiful.Affordable, well made, very beautiful watchesRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Feels the presentation is striking for the money.offers a striking presentation for the moneyRead it in context
    • The Limited Edition Highlights the quality of execution relative to the sub-$900 price.each of these watches is just $899 plus taxWatch from 1:54
    • WatchChris Calls the watch very nicely priced.This is a really nicely priced watch also.Watch from 6:13
    • WatchChris Concludes it is really well priced.that's why I think this is really well priced.Watch from 7:09
    • Fratello Sees it as evidence microbrands beat big brands on value for money.friendlier-priced microbrands offer severe competition and alternativesRead it in context
  • Ceramic case is the defining highlight4 of 7
    • Deployant Considers the ceramic case the standout feature of the collection.The ceramic case is unquestionably the star of the Summit Collection.Read it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Feels the ceramic construction makes the classic field/pilot case shape shine on the wrist.it’s the construction that really makes this form shine on the wristRead it in context
    • WatchTimeItIs Considers the ceramic case construction a significant plus.The fact that they were making this in ceramic is also a great plus.Watch from 0:27
    • WatchChris Thinks the ceramic case looks cool, even if not strictly necessary.Obviously, a ceramic case isn't entirely necessary, but it looks cool.Watch from 2:51
  • Comfortable on a wide range of wrists4 of 7
    • Deployant Believes the 38mm sizing suits a broad range of wearers comfortably.The result is a watch comfortable across a broad spectrum of wearers.Read it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Considers it a featherweight, comfortable daily wearer thanks to ceramic and modest proportions.make the Summit a featherweight, comfortable daily-wear optionRead it in context
    • Fratello Describes it as easy to wear and solid-feeling.The Summit is easy to wear, solid-feeling, and very GADA-ishRead it in context
    • WatchChris Says it wears very well on a 7.5-inch wrist.It wears great on my 7 and a half inch wrist.Watch from 4:44
  • Oversized crown pleasant and easy to operate4 of 7
    • Fratello Is not bothered by the oversized crown and finds it pleasant to operate.it is very easy and enjoyable to operateRead it in context
    • The Limited Edition Finds the oversized crown satisfying and tactile to operate.Absolutely love the oversized crown. It's really satisfying and tactile to use.Watch from 1:28
    • The Limited Edition Initially wary of the large crown, but feels it gives the slim case more masculine presence.Actually, it lends a a masculinity to the caseWatch from 4:41
    • WatchTimeItIs Enjoys the slightly oversized crown, which also operates well.the crown is slightly oversized compared to the watchWatch from 1:25
    • WatchChris Finds the large, rubber-gripped crown very easy to use.a very large, very grippy crown, very easy to useWatch from 3:48
    • The Limited Edition Considers the crown operation and screw-down very well executed.Screw it down. Very, very nicely executed.Watch from 1:54
  • Pilot-style dial is highly legible4 of 7
    • aBlogtoWatch Considers the classic pilot layout timeless and very functional.this classic pilot watch layout is both timeless and extremely functionalRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Praises crisp numerals and minute scale for at-a-glance legibility.make legibility easy at a glanceRead it in context
    • The Limited Edition Likes the lollipop seconds hand and distinct hour and minute hands, finding them very legible.Super legible. very very cool.Watch from 2:49
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Considers the field-watch dial highly legible.I like the field watch aesthetic. It's very legible.Watch from 3:18
    • WatchChris Finds the dial highly legible thanks to its contrast.it is really, really legible as wellWatch from 6:13
Show 14 more
  • Versatile go-anywhere everyday watch4 of 7
    • Deployant Credits the dual straps with making it versatile for sport and everyday use.ensuring versatility on the slopes or in daily lifeRead it in context
    • Fratello Considers it a genuine go-anywhere, do-anything watch with 100m water resistance.very GADA-ish (or just GADA, with a 100m water resistance rating)Read it in context
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Feels it suits formal and casual contexts alike.wear it to any kind of style depending on formal or casualWatch from 3:47
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Says, depending on strap, it works with a suit or jeans and a t-shirt.you could really wear this to work with a suit or just casually with jeansWatch from 3:47
    • WatchTimeItIs Sees it as an easy grab-and-go watch that matches many clothes.it's a great easy watch to throw on. It matches with a lot of your clothes.Watch from 1:52
  • Slim case dimensions well proportioned3 of 7
    • Deployant Finds the 38mm by 10mm dimensions well balanced.the case strikes a balanced profileRead it in context
    • Fratello Considers the 10mm thickness very wearable.the case has a very wearable 10mm profileRead it in context
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Finds the 38mm, 10mm-thick, 45mm lug-to-lug dimensions excellent.The dimensions of this watch are great.Watch from 2:21
  • Wears compact and close to the wrist3 of 7
    • Fratello Fits the reviewer's 18cm wrist perfectly and feels more compact than a 38mm Hamilton Khaki Field.It sits perfectly on my 18cm wrist and feels a bit more compactRead it in context
    • WatchTimeItIs Feels more like a 36mm watch on the wrist due to compact lug-to-lug.it wears more like a 36 mm watchWatch from 0:00
    • WatchChris Notes how thin and close to the wrist it wears.You could see how thin that wears to the wrist.Watch from 4:44
  • Ring counterweight on seconds hand is a charming detail3 of 7
    • aBlogtoWatch Enjoys the ring counterweight on the seconds hand framing the logo.The seconds hand also brings a sense of fun to the summitRead it in context
    • WatchTimeItIs Likes the seconds hand detail with the circle on the counterweight.the little circle um on the counterwe looks really goodWatch from 1:25
    • WatchChris Enjoys the looped seconds-hand counterweight passing over the logo.Very cool little detail, not necessary, but I really like it.Watch from 2:22
  • Generous, playful lume application3 of 7
    • Deployant Finds the full-lume dial both practical and playful.It transforms the watch into something both practical and delightfully playful.Read it in context
    • The Limited Edition Enjoys the blue and green lume interplay against the textured black dial.I like the fact they've interplayed with blue and green.Watch from 3:19
    • The Limited Edition Finds the fully lumed Bluebird dial distinctive.is loomed up. Super cool. Very different.Watch from 3:46
    • WatchChris Finds the lume generously applied to hands and indices.Very liberally applied to the hands and the indicesWatch from 5:44
  • Attractive, thoughtfully resolved design3 of 7
    • The Limited Edition Calls the watch unpretentious, well designed and fun in colourway.It's not pretentious. It just has good design, funky colorwaysWatch from 4:16
    • WatchTimeItIs Feels the design has been carefully considered and everything makes sense.They've really thought well about this design.Watch from 0:57
    • WatchChris Calls it a very good-looking watch.this is a very good looking watchWatch from 1:54
    • WatchChris Thinks it looks fantastic on the wrist.Watch from 4:16
    • WatchChris Sees it as very attractive, especially for the price.I think it's a very attractive watch especially for that price.Watch from 7:37
  • Brushed ceramic finish looks refined, not plastic2 of 7
    • aBlogtoWatch Finds the linear brushing deep and evenly applied across case sides and lugs.the linear brushing is deep, almost grooved in some lights, but evenly appliedRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Likes the polished chamfers adding reflectivity and a sense of quality.add some welcome reflectivity and a sense of quality to the overall presentationRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Feels the mostly brushed finish gives the white ceramic a more purposeful, athletic look.the largely brushed finishing here adds a purposeful touchRead it in context
    • Fratello Surprised the ceramic avoids a shiny, plastic look.ceramic doesn’t always need to be a shiny, plastic-looking materialRead it in context
    • Fratello Rates the surface finishing more attractive than most ceramic watches, though not Blancpain-level.more attractive than most other ceramic watches out thereRead it in context
    • Fratello Finds the satin and brushed finishing shows best on the black Overcast case.just show up better on the black ceramic editionRead it in context
  • Clean, uncluttered dial typography2 of 7
    • The Limited Edition Describes the dial as very clean.Really, really clean dial.Watch from 1:28
    • WatchTimeItIs Finds the dial font clean and sterile.The font on the watch looks nice and clean and sterile.Watch from 1:52
  • Sailcloth rubber strap tough yet comfortable2 of 7
    • Deployant Finds the sailcloth rubber strap tough yet comfortable.tough enough to take on the elements, yet comfortable on the wristRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Praises the strap's texture and substantial yet flexible feel adding comfort.a well-executed texture and a substantial yet flexible feelRead it in context
  • Quick-release bars make strap changes easy2 of 7
    • Fratello Finds strap changes hassle-free thanks to quick-release spring bars.Switching straps isn’t an issue because the mounted sailcloth straps have a quick-release systemRead it in context
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Finds strap changes very easy thanks to quick-release pins.Exchanging straps is super easyWatch from 2:50
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Values the 20mm lug width for changing straps to suit mood.allows for you to change your straps depending on what your mood isWatch from 2:50
  • Water resistance suits everyday and water use2 of 7
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Feels comfortable taking it into water thanks to 100m water resistance.you can take the watch for a spin in the waterWatch from 5:14
    • WatchChris Considers 100m water resistance great for an everyday watch.100 m of water resistance, which of course is great for an everyday watchWatch from 3:19
  • Miyota calibre robust and easy to service2 of 7
    • Deployant Sees the Miyota 9039 as highly dependable and robust.it’s as dependable as a Toyota Hilux rugged, reliable, and near unbreakableRead it in context
    • Deployant Feels durability and ease of servicing outweigh the rotor noise.Still, the trade-off is worth itRead it in context
    • aBlogtoWatch Values the calibre as rugged and easy to service.the 9039 is a rugged, easy-to-service staple of many independent brandsRead it in context
  • Classic field-watch look with modern materials2 of 7
    • Fratello Finds the watches evocative of classic tool watches while remaining thoroughly modern.Earthen Co. ensured these watches are as modern as a HublotRead it in context
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Appreciates the combination of classic field-watch aesthetic with modern case materials.the field watch aesthetic paired with a modern case,Watch from 2:50
  • White case and black dial contrast stands out2 of 7
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Likes the white ceramic case contrasted with the black dial, finding it stealthy.I very much like these white ceramic cases with the black contrasting dialsWatch from 1:52
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Values white for the contrast and pop of colour it gives.White is a great color because it gives contrastWatch from 2:21
    • WatchTimeItIs Considers the white-case, black-dial combination unique enough to be a home run.The white watch with the black dial is just unique enoughWatch from 3:50

Most criticised

  • Rotor is noticeably audible2 of 7
    • Deployant Dislikes the audible spinning noise of the unidirectional rotor.it produces an audible spinning noise when in free motionRead it in context
    • WatchTimeItIs Notes the rotor is quite audible when moving the wrist.When you move your wrist, you can hear the rotor.Watch from 2:50
  • White strap impractical without a darker alternative1 of 7
    • WatchChris Names the white strap as the single complaint about the watch.The only complaint that I have about this watch is the white strap.Watch from 4:44
    • WatchChris Expects the white strap to get dirty quickly and not last long.this will get dirtier way faster than you would expectWatch from 5:14
    • WatchChris Wishes a second, darker strap was included or offered.If this came with two straps, it would make it a little bit easier to wear.Watch from 5:14
  • Ceramic case can shatter on impact1 of 7
    • Nikolaus Hirsch Warns the durable ceramic case can shatter if dropped or struck.then they can shatter. So, be careful of that.Watch from 5:43

Open a point to see who said it and jump to that moment in their review.

By aspect

PositiveMixedNegative

How reviewers judged each aspect; one square per reviewer who discussed it
DialPraised
Case & proportionsPraised
ValuePraised
DesignPraised
WearabilityPraised
Bracelet & strapPraised
MovementMostly liked
VersatilityPraised
Finishing & buildPraised
OriginalityPraised
FunctionalityPraised

Was this consensus useful?

The reviews

7 counted, 1 more for context

Remontoir summarises; the reviewers did the work. Watch and read the originals for the full picture.

Nikolaus Hirsch

This brand is changing the game for ceramic watches

Video, 7 minHands-on reviewNov 2025

Very positiveRecommends

Enthusiastic about the Summit's pairing of field-watch styling with a modern ceramic case. The reviewer praises its dimensions, legibility, versatility and value, while warning that the case edges are sharp and ceramic can shatter on impact.

Suits: Wearers wanting one versatile watch for suits, casual wear, water and skiing

What they said, point by point
Designpositive
  • Likes the white ceramic case contrasted with the black dial, finding it stealthy. 1:52
  • Values white for the contrast and pop of colour it gives. 2:21
  • Appreciates the combination of classic field-watch aesthetic with modern case materials. 2:50
Case & proportionsmixed
  • Finds the 38mm, 10mm-thick, 45mm lug-to-lug dimensions excellent. 2:21
  • Notes the ceramic case edges are sharp and can scratch straps during changes. 2:21
  • Warns the durable ceramic case can shatter if dropped or struck. 5:43
Dialpositive
  • Considers the field-watch dial highly legible. 3:18
Versatilitypositive
  • Feels it suits formal and casual contexts alike. 3:47
  • Says, depending on strap, it works with a suit or jeans and a t-shirt. 3:47
  • Considers skiing an ideal environment for this watch. 4:16
Bracelet & strappositive
  • Finds strap changes very easy thanks to quick-release pins. 2:50
  • Values the 20mm lug width for changing straps to suit mood. 2:50
Functionalitypositive
  • Feels comfortable taking it into water thanks to 100m water resistance. 5:14
  • Sees the screw-down crown as evidence of thoughtful detailing. 5:14
Valuepositive
  • Calls the price a very good value proposition given ceramic cases usually cost far more. 3:18
Compared with
  • IWC Pilot's Watch Lake Tahoe: Also ceramic but much more expensive; Summit offers better value.

Watch on YouTube

aBlogtoWatch

Hands-On: The Earthen Co. Summit Watch Does Affordable Ceramic Case Design Right

ArticleHands-on reviewOct 2025Sean Lorentzen

PositiveRecommends

Sees the Summit as a strong debut that brings a true ceramic case to a sub-$1,000 price, with quality brushing, a legible IWC Mark XI-inspired dial, light comfortable wear and a solid if unremarkable movement.

What the review says, point by point
Case & proportionspositive
  • Feels the ceramic construction makes the classic field/pilot case shape shine on the wrist.
  • Notes the white coloration makes the 38mm case feel closer to 40mm.
Finishing & buildpositive
  • Finds the linear brushing deep and evenly applied across case sides and lugs.
  • Likes the polished chamfers adding reflectivity and a sense of quality.
  • Feels the mostly brushed finish gives the white ceramic a more purposeful, athletic look.
Wearabilitypositive
  • Considers it a featherweight, comfortable daily wearer thanks to ceramic and modest proportions.
  • Notes the white hue has the opposite of a slimming effect on the wrist.
Dialpositive
  • Considers the classic pilot layout timeless and very functional.
  • Praises crisp numerals and minute scale for at-a-glance legibility.
  • Enjoys the ring counterweight on the seconds hand framing the logo.
  • Likes the polished hands adding light play to the matte dial.
Originalitymixed
  • Notes clear IWC Mark XI influence in the dial but considers it no bad thing.
  • Sees the true ceramic case as rare in the entry-level market.
Movementpositive
  • Considers performance unrevolutionary but solid for the price point.
  • Values the calibre as rugged and easy to service.
Bracelet & strappositive
  • Praises the strap's texture and substantial yet flexible feel adding comfort.
Versatilitypositive
  • Finds it works with various strap colours, especially signal orange.
Valuepositive
  • Praises bringing a full ceramic case experience to an approachable price.
  • Feels the presentation is striking for the money.
Compared with
  • IWC Mark XI: Summit's dial and hands clearly borrow from the Mark XI, which reviewer considers fine.

Read on ablogtowatch.com

WatchChris

How is This Ceramic Cased Automatic Sports Watch so Cheap?

Video, 8 minHands-on reviewOct 2025

Very positiveRecommends

Finds the ski-inspired ceramic Summit an attractive, thin, comfortable and very legible watch that is exceptionally well priced for a ceramic case. The one real complaint is the white strap, which gets dirty quickly and comes without a darker alternative.

What they said, point by point
Designpositive
  • Calls it a very good-looking watch. 1:54
  • Thinks it looks fantastic on the wrist. 4:16
  • Sees it as very attractive, especially for the price. 7:37
Dialpositive
  • Enjoys the looped seconds-hand counterweight passing over the logo. 2:22
  • Finds the lume generously applied to hands and indices. 5:44
  • Wishes the seconds hand had lume, given the sporty purpose. 5:44
  • Finds the dial highly legible thanks to its contrast. 6:13
Case & proportionspositive
  • Thinks the ceramic case looks cool, even if not strictly necessary. 2:51
  • Finds the large, rubber-gripped crown very easy to use. 3:48
Wearabilitypositive
  • Says it wears very well on a 7.5-inch wrist. 4:44
  • Notes how thin and close to the wrist it wears. 4:44
Bracelet & strapmixed
  • Names the white strap as the single complaint about the watch. 4:44
  • Expects the white strap to get dirty quickly and not last long. 5:14
  • Wishes a second, darker strap was included or offered. 5:14
  • Likes the milled stainless steel buckle. 5:14
Movementpositive
  • Values the Miyota 9039 because it keeps the watch thin. 3:19
Functionalitypositive
  • Considers 100m water resistance great for an everyday watch. 3:19
Valuepositive
  • Calls the watch very nicely priced. 6:13
  • Argues it undercuts even used ceramic watches from major brands. 6:41
  • Concludes it is really well priced. 7:09
Originalitypositive
  • Notes it is the first sub-$1,000 microbrand ceramic watch featured on the channel, calling that significant. 1:25

Watch on YouTube

WatchTimeItIs

Are These The Best Value Ceramic Watches?

Video, 4 minHands-on reviewSep 2025

Very positiveRecommends

The reviewer sees the Summit as a thoughtfully designed, compact ceramic field watch at a competitive sub-€1,000 price. The black-dial white version is the favourite and a personal home run, with a noisy rotor from the budget movement as the main downside.

Suits: Field-watch fans seeking a compact fit, especially for summer wear

What they said, point by point
Wearabilitypositive
  • Feels more like a 36mm watch on the wrist due to compact lug-to-lug. 0:00
Case & proportionspositive
  • Considers the ceramic case construction a significant plus. 0:27
  • Enjoys the slightly oversized crown, which also operates well. 1:25
Designpositive
  • Feels the design has been carefully considered and everything makes sense. 0:57
  • Prefers the black-dial variant for its tougher look. 0:57
  • Finds the baby-blue strap version a bit too feminine for personal taste. 0:57
Dialpositive
  • Likes the seconds hand detail with the circle on the counterweight. 1:25
  • Finds the dial font clean and sterile. 1:52
Versatilitymixed
  • Sees it as an easy grab-and-go watch that matches many clothes. 1:52
  • Thinks the white ceramic case makes it better as a summer watch than a daily wearer. 1:52
Movementmixed
  • Views the movement as where the brand cut corners, acceptable under €1,000. 2:22
  • Notes the rotor is quite audible when moving the wrist. 2:50
Valuepositive
  • Considers a ceramic watch under €1,000 a competitive, good price. 2:22
Originalitypositive
  • Considers the white-case, black-dial combination unique enough to be a home run. 3:50
Compared with
  • Hamilton Khaki Field: Hamilton's long lugs make it wear bigger; Summit wears smaller.

Watch on YouTube

Deployant

New & Reviewed: Earthen Watch Co., Summit Collection

ArticleHands-on reviewAug 2025Stanley Leung

Very positiveRecommends

Sees the Summit as a successful attempt to make ceramic watches affordable, praising the well-finished ceramic case, playful full-lume dial, comfortable straps and dependable movement. The only complaint is the audible Miyota rotor.

Suits: Younger or budget-conscious enthusiasts wanting an affordable ceramic sports watch

Disclosure: Brand loaner

What the review says, point by point
Case & proportionspositive
  • Considers the ceramic case the standout feature of the collection.
  • Finds the 38mm by 10mm dimensions well balanced.
Finishing & buildpositive
  • Finds the finishing level impressive for the price point.
  • Notes the satin and brushed textures evoke snow and ice, more visible on black than white.
Wearabilitypositive
  • Believes the 38mm sizing suits a broad range of wearers comfortably.
Dialpositive
  • Finds the full-lume dial both practical and playful.
Bracelet & strappositive
  • Finds the sailcloth rubber strap tough yet comfortable.
  • Values the NATO strap as a relaxed alternative for casual wear.
Movementmixed
  • Sees the Miyota 9039 as highly dependable and robust.
  • Dislikes the audible spinning noise of the unidirectional rotor.
  • Feels durability and ease of servicing outweigh the rotor noise.
Valuepositive
  • Notes no other automatic ceramic watches seem available at this price.
  • Concludes it is affordable, well made and beautiful.
Designpositive
  • Finds the ski-infused pilot's design refreshing and youthful.
Versatilitypositive
  • Credits the dual straps with making it versatile for sport and everyday use.
Compared with
  • Watch Ho & Co. x Selten Jui: Similar-priced microbrand alternative with same movement and affordable MOP dial.
  • Ba111od Chapter 7: Similar-priced alternative offering an affordable certified chronometer.

Read on deployant.com

Fratello

Earthen Co.’s New Summit Collection Convinced Me About Ceramic Watches

ArticleHands-on reviewAug 2025Robert-Jan Broer

Very positiveRecommends

Sees the Summit as a well-specced, modern ceramic tool watch that wears compactly, has unusually attractive satin and brushed ceramic finishing, and offers strong value at $899. The Overcast especially won the reviewer over to ceramic watches.

Suits: Those seeking an affordable utilitarian, adventure-oriented go-anywhere watch

What the review says, point by point
Designpositive
  • Finds the watches evocative of classic tool watches while remaining thoroughly modern.
  • Enjoys the Blue Bird's blue gaskets for adding a fresh look.
  • Still gets Explorer or Mark-series vibes after handling, though the ceramic makes it a different experience.
Dialpositive
  • Likes the faux-patina lume on the markers and hands.
  • Initially mistook the small logo above six for a broad arrow before seeing a skier on a mountain.
Case & proportionspositive
  • Considers the 10mm thickness very wearable.
  • Is not bothered by the oversized crown and finds it pleasant to operate.
Wearabilitypositive
  • Fits the reviewer's 18cm wrist perfectly and feels more compact than a 38mm Hamilton Khaki Field.
  • Describes it as easy to wear and solid-feeling.
Bracelet & strappositive
  • Finds strap changes hassle-free thanks to quick-release spring bars.
Finishing & buildpositive
  • Surprised the ceramic avoids a shiny, plastic look.
  • Rates the surface finishing more attractive than most ceramic watches, though not Blancpain-level.
  • Finds the satin and brushed finishing shows best on the black Overcast case.
Movementmixed
  • Notes a Swiss movement would have raised the price significantly.
Versatilitypositive
  • Considers it a genuine go-anywhere, do-anything watch with 100m water resistance.
  • Believes buyers wanting a utilitarian watch will enjoy it.
Valuepositive
  • Calls a ceramic watch with this finishing at $899 quite a deal.
  • Sees it as evidence microbrands beat big brands on value for money.
Compared with
  • Hamilton Khaki Field Auto 38mm: Summit feels more compact and holds up very well against it.
  • Rolex Explorer: Evokes Explorer tool-watch vibes but offers a more modern ceramic experience.

Read on fratellowatches.com

The Limited Edition

Introducing The Earthen Co Watches! | Overcast, Summit Blue Bird & Summit Whiteout

Video, 6 minFirst lookAug 2025

Very positiveRecommends

An enthusiastic launch-day look at three Summit colourways. The reviewer praises the compact ceramic case, tactile oversized crown, legible lollipop-hand dial and playful lume, and frames the $899 price as notable for the execution.

Suits: Those wanting a compact, fun, unpretentious ceramic watch with standout lume

Disclosure: Retailer stock

What they said, point by point
Case & proportionspositive
  • Finds the oversized crown satisfying and tactile to operate. 1:28
  • Initially wary of the large crown, but feels it gives the slim case more masculine presence. 4:41
  • Values the ceramic construction for its scratch resistance. 4:41
  • Likes the slightly stepped bezel and domed sapphire as added design interest. 5:11
Dialpositive
  • Describes the dial as very clean. 1:28
  • Likes the lollipop seconds hand and distinct hour and minute hands, finding them very legible. 2:49
  • Enjoys the blue and green lume interplay against the textured black dial. 3:19
  • Finds the fully lumed Bluebird dial distinctive. 3:46
Designpositive
  • Calls the watch unpretentious, well designed and fun in colourway. 4:16
  • Was surprised the all-white Whiteout became the favourite of the three. 3:46
Finishing & buildpositive
  • Considers the crown operation and screw-down very well executed. 1:54
Bracelet & strappositive
  • Appreciates the rubber on the inside of the strap for versatility. 2:22
  • Enjoys the way the strap stitching glows under UV. 3:46
Wearabilitypositive
  • Finds the 38mm by 9.9mm dimensions very svelte. 4:41
  • Says the watch gets noticed on the wrist, in a good way. 4:16
Valuepositive
  • Highlights the quality of execution relative to the sub-$900 price. 1:54

Watch on YouTube

Also covered by

teddybeby

$899 Ceramic Field Watches That Don't Suck - Earthen Summit Collection Hands-On Review

Video, 4 minNewsSep 2025

Positive

A short, largely scripted overview of the Summit collection that praises its ceramic case, proportions and value. Light caveats cover the Bluebird's reduced daylight legibility and the audible Miyota movement. It calls Earthen a brand to watch.

Suits: Outdoor enthusiasts wanting an affordable ceramic field watch

Not a review of the watch in hand (news, a guide or a reaction), so it isn't counted.

Low-confidence reading: The video is short and reads like a rewritten press release with a founder quote. Despite the description's hands-on claim, there is little evidence of actual handling, and the chapter timestamps don't match the video length.

What they said, point by point
Case & proportionspositive
  • Feels the size and thickness balance ruggedness with wearability. 0:58
  • Considers the colour-accented screw-down crown practical with gloves and stylish. 1:27
Dialmixed
  • Finds that the beige lume on the Overcast adds warmth. 1:27
  • Notes that the Bluebird's full-lume dial gives up some daylight readability. 1:56
Designpositive
  • Sees the black Overcast as a model of classic restraint. 1:27
  • Finds the Whiteout's monochrome look sleek and modern. 2:25
Movementmixed
  • Calls the movement dependable and responsive but not quiet. 2:53
Bracelet & strappositive
  • Includes the high-quality strap among the watch's value highlights. 2:53
Valuepositive
  • Says the watches feel like they should cost twice the price. 2:53
  • Views the 10% US tariff as a minor cost for a unique piece. 3:20

Watch on YouTube

Specifications

Case
38mm, ceramic (white or black), steel caseback
Thickness
10mm
Lug to lug
45mm
Movement
Miyota 9039 (automatic)
Power reserve
42 hours
Water resistance
100m
Crystal
sapphire
Bracelet or strap
sailcloth-pattern rubber strap plus a NATO strap, quick-release
Announced
August 2025
List price (US)
$899US$899 (excl.

Creator Consensus is built only from what reviewers said. Prices, retailers and any commercial relationship never affect it. How consensus works