Each marker on the ring is one counted review, coloured by its verdict.

Seiko

5 Sports SNXS

SRPK89K137.4mmautomatic$395 list priceAnnounced April 2024

A 37.4mm Seiko 5 Sports series that revives the case shape of the discontinued SNXS field-sport watches, with the crown at 4 o'clock and a day-date display. This black-dial version runs on the 4R36 automatic with hand-winding and hacking and comes on a steel bracelet.

Seiko product page

Creator Consensus

Positive

7 reviews: 6 positive, 1 mixed, 0 negative. 6 of 7 recommend it.

Nearly all reviewers say the case finishing punches above its price. Most praise the sturdy solid links and end links, as well as the orange seconds hand as a welcome accent on the dial. Most also find the stamped clasp short on micro-adjustment. Reviewers describe it as comfortable for all-day wear and easy to dress up or down.

Where they differ. Value divides opinion. Most call it worth the asking price, while several fault the Hardlex crystal and the steep price climb over its predecessors. Sizing splits reviewers too: several like the compact vintage proportions, but several others find the narrow 18mm lugs undersized.

Most praised

Case finishing punches above its price6 of 7
- Long Island Watch Praises the case polishing.beautiful polishing on it wonderfulWatch from 3:46
- Average Bros Admires the chamfered case and lug transitions.Look at the transition there. Beautifully done.Watch from 8:11
- Average Bros Praises the fine transitions between satin brushing and high polish.So very clean, well executed here, guys.Watch from 13:52
- WatchChris Finds the case finishing as good as Seiko's pricier non-5 models.really just as good as many of their other watches that aren't in the SEO 5 lineWatch from 5:13
- ANACHRONIST Sees the case finishing as a major improvement made with more precise machining.the finishing on this case though is a big step upWatch from 4:48
- ANACHRONIST Praises sharp lines and brushed/polished transitions, likening them to Longines-level finishing.the lines are extremely sharp I'd say it's on parWatch from 4:48
- Ben's Watch Club Mostly brushed finish is predictable but a major step up, plus drilled lugs and an easy crown cutout.it's nonetheless a major step upWatch from 6:17
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Sees the case as a clear improvement in finish over the older SNXS models.another level of finish over the older snxs modelsWatch from 2:50
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Considers the finishing good for the price point.the Finish looks good considering the price pointWatch from 2:50
Solid links and end links feel sturdy5 of 7
- Long Island Watch Likes the solid-link construction and clasp.the bracelet is solid link not folded link uh it's a nice claspWatch from 2:49
- YoureTerrific Praises solid links, solid end links and good tolerances.The bracelet feels pretty solid and has solid end linksWatch from 4:50
- Average Bros Notes solid links and end links, a big improvement over the older hollow SNXS bracelets.the older variations of that SNXS line, very hollow, very chintzy here. Lot better.Watch from 8:38
- WatchChris Appreciates the solid links and end links.the bracelet is solid you have solid links on this watchWatch from 2:22
- ANACHRONIST Welcomes the move to solid links.the bracelet gets a big upgrade now with solid in linksWatch from 5:16
- ANACHRONIST Finds the bracelet feels heftier and more durable.the bracelet just feels more Hefty more durableWatch from 5:16
Orange seconds hand adds a welcome accent5 of 7
- Long Island Watch Enjoys the orange seconds hand as a colour accent.little pop of color with the orange second's handWatch from 5:45
- YoureTerrific Likes the contrasting chapter ring and the orange seconds hand.I really like that this has a contrasting colorWatch from 6:18
- WatchChris Enjoys the orange seconds hand for its vintage feel.they put an orange secondhand so it gives you a little bit of a vintage VibeWatch from 2:22
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Thinks the orange seconds hand suits every colourway and accepts that it lacks lume.the orange secondhand works for me it goes well with all of the colorsWatch from 1:53
- Ben's Watch Club Raised chapter ring and orange seconds hand add some individuality.the raised chapter ring and orange second hand do provide some individualismWatch from 10:09
Attractive dial colourways4 of 7
- Long Island Watch Likes the dial colour even if the sunray isn't bright.beautiful blue dial not exactly a bright SunrayWatch from 5:15
- Average Bros Finds the golden dial fantastic, with a warm tone and a nice pop.I think this golden dial here is fantasticWatch from 2:25
- Average Bros Likes the retro gold tone that stays understated.that golden tone is a bit retro without being loudWatch from 14:19
- WatchChris Likes how the black dial pairs with the creamy lume.that black and creamy color I think goes really well togetherWatch from 1:54
- WatchChris Likes the simplicity and overall colour combination.I think it looks really good very smart looking very clean lookingWatch from 8:07
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Likes the black, finds the blue sportier, and sees the tan as more unique.I like the black here in the middle the blue is sportierWatch from 0:55
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Considers the tan version distinctive and appealing.the tan has a neat look too a bit more uniqueWatch from 0:55
Comfortable for all-day wear4 of 7
- Long Island Watch Finds the weight distribution excellent.it feels so much better in the hand the weight just distribution is perfectWatch from 2:49
- YoureTerrific Finds it comfortable on a 7-inch wrist.Now it feels very good on the 7-in wristWatch from 4:50
- ANACHRONIST Describes it as comfortable for all-day wear.the watch has sort of an all day Comfort kind of feelWatch from 6:13
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Says it wears comfortably.they do wear comfortablyWatch from 2:50
Dresses up or down with ease4 of 7
- Average Bros Finds this variant more versatile and less funky than the first three revival models.It feels just a lot more versatile, slightly less funkyWatch from 2:25
- Average Bros Imagines it dressed up on a glossy black exotic leather strap.that would just dress up this watch so wellWatch from 14:48
- Average Bros Can be worn casually on the bracelet when not dressed up.when you don't want to dress it up, you totally can wear it on this braceletWatch from 14:48
- WatchChris Suitable both dressed up and for swimming.you could wear this with a suit you could wear this goingWatch from 5:41
- ANACHRONIST Considers it a go-anywhere watch compared with the sterner old model.you might say this is a more versatile watch as well like a go anywhere watchWatch from 6:13
- Ben's Watch Club Subdued matte design invites everyday, multi-purpose use.a map finish that invites everyday multi-purpose usageWatch from 11:08

Show 13 more

Worth the asking price4 of 7
- Long Island Watch Defends price against cheaper rivals by noting Seiko's in-house design and development.but Seiko designed developed everything hereWatch from 6:43
- YoureTerrific Personally judges the $415 price worthwhile.is $415 worth it for me? I regret to inform you, yesWatch from 7:16
- YoureTerrific Adores the watches at this price and is considering buying one.I still adore these watches for $415Watch from 7:44
- Average Bros Calls the discounted retailer price a great deal.I think that's one heck of a deal.Watch from 0:59
- Average Bros Thinks few rivals can beat it at the price.at the price point, it's really tough to beat the street cred offersWatch from 15:17
- WatchChris Still judges it worth the money if Hardlex is acceptable.if you could look past the hardlex I definitely think it's worth the moneyWatch from 9:05
Compact vintage sizing suits the style3 of 7
- Long Island Watch Recommends it for people with smaller wrists.folks with smaller wrists will certainly certainly enjoyWatch from 8:09
- Long Island Watch Finds the vintage look suits the 37mm size.really nice vintagey looking kind of fits the motifWatch from 7:12
- YoureTerrific Feels the throwback crystal and small size combine very effectively.I think it all works really well togetherWatch from 3:52
- YoureTerrific Calls the 37.4mm size perfect on a 7-inch wrist for this style.37.4 mm on my 7-in wrist, in this style, I think this is perfectWatch from 3:24
- ANACHRONIST Glad Seiko kept a smaller case size instead of going to 40mm.I'm glad they kept the smaller size only bumping aWatch from 4:20
- ANACHRONIST Finds the 44.5mm lug-to-lug keeps it subtle.with a lug to Lug of 44 and a half it still manages to be subtleWatch from 5:16
Hacking and hand-winding a key upgrade3 of 7
- YoureTerrific Sees hacking and hand-winding as the biggest improvement.the biggest improvement here is that the movement hand winds and it hacksWatch from 5:20
- ANACHRONIST Appreciates the addition of hacking and hand-winding.it does get hacking and hand winding finallyWatch from 5:45
- Ben's Watch Club Values the addition of hacking and hand winding.useful features such as hackingWatch from 9:12
100m water resistance covers everyday needs3 of 7
- YoureTerrific Says 100m water resistance is all most people need.100 m of water resistance is greatWatch from 6:18
- ANACHRONIST Values the significant water resistance upgrade to 100m.lot less worried about this watch getting wetWatch from 6:42
- Ben's Watch Club The 10 bar rating gives performance matching its sporty aesthetic.giving this sporty watch a level of performance that better matches its aestheticWatch from 9:41
Bracelet good enough to rival aftermarket options2 of 7
- Long Island Watch Considers the bracelet so good an aftermarket replacement may be unnecessary.this bracelet is really really niceWatch from 3:17
- Average Bros Thinks the three-link bracelet looks like something bought aftermarket.This looks like something that you would pay typically aftermarket for.Watch from 12:55
Curved case shape sits better on the wrist2 of 7
- ANACHRONIST Despite being thicker, the curved, organic case shape helps it sit better on the wrist.has like a gentle curve and the whole shape is more organicWatch from 5:16
- Ben's Watch Club Case shape is far better tailored than the original, with taller sides and curved lugs.here the shape is much more well tailored with taller sides and curved lugsWatch from 5:18
- Ben's Watch Club The new case shape makes it wear much better on the wrist.the watch wears much better on the wristWatch from 5:18
Vintage look without feeling like an old watch2 of 7
- YoureTerrific Notes it looks vintage by design but does not feel like an old watch.but they don't really feel like oldWatch from 3:52
- WatchChris Wears like a vintage-sized watch while feeling modern.it actually wears like a vintage sized watch however it feels very modernWatch from 2:22
Handsomely proportioned on the wrist2 of 7
- Long Island Watch Thinks it looks well proportioned on the wrist, with nice chaptering.it still looks like a nicely nicely proportioned watchWatch from 8:37
- Average Bros Finds it handsome and well proportioned on the wrist.Quite handsome, beautifully proportioned.Watch from 10:02
Contrasting chapter ring frames the dial neatly2 of 7
- Average Bros Likes the precisely aligned sloped chapter ring.take a look at that slopedWatch from 3:24
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Likes how the contrasting chapter ring frames the dial.the first thing I liked about the watches was the contrasting chapteringWatch from 1:24
Clear, easy-to-read dial2 of 7
- Long Island Watch Finds it easy to read.easy to read easy to tell the timeWatch from 7:42
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Finds the polished and brushed hands easy to read in any lighting.always be easy to see and tell the timeWatch from 1:53
Lume stronger than expected2 of 7
- Average Bros Finds the lume brighter than expected for a dressier watch.especially brighter than you might expect from a watch that is on the dressier sideWatch from 13:24
- WatchChris Finds the lume excellent and long-lasting, though wants lume on the seconds hand.the Luma bright is excellent on this watchWatch from 9:33
Handset finely cut and well executed2 of 7
- Average Bros Calls the handset fantastic, finely detailed and well executed.Beautifully executed, finely detailed, and it just I don't knowWatch from 7:43
- Ben's Watch Club Macro footage shows better-cut hands and cleaner markers.better cut hands and markers that are cleaner tooWatch from 10:38
Genuine Seiko heritage rather than a homage2 of 7
- Average Bros Appreciates that it comes from the brand that created the look, unlike homages.this is a re-release from the brand that created this lookWatch from 15:46
- WatchChris Sees Seiko's history and iconic status as a reason to buy it.Seiko make iconic watches they've been around for a long timeWatch from 10:31

Most criticised

Stamped clasp has limited micro-adjustment5 of 7
- Long Island Watch Notes one fewer micro-adjust position than the older model; clasp unremarkable.nothing special there but a decent claspWatch from 4:45
- YoureTerrific Finds the stamped clasp not especially nice, though it offers two micro-adjustments.The stamped clasp isn't especially niceWatch from 4:50
- WatchChris Wishes for more micro-adjust positions; notes no half links.do I wish there was more micro adjust of courseWatch from 6:09
- Ben's Watch Club Clasp offers only two micro-adjustment holes, roughly half a link of range.a mere two micro adjustment HS which only gives you roughly a half link rangeWatch from 7:15
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Criticises the stamped-steel clasp, which has only two micro-adjustment positions.stamped steel and only two micro adjusts on the classWatch from 4:16
Narrow 18mm lug width looks undersized3 of 7
- Average Bros Wishes the lug width were 19 or 20mm; 18mm with heavy taper feels small.I do wish it was at least a 19 mm. 18's a bit small for me.Watch from 8:11
- Ben's Watch Club Thinks 20mm lugs would suit better, as the 18mm band looks swallowed up.I think a 20 mil lug width would have been a better fitWatch from 6:45
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Finds the 18mm lug width narrow and inconvenient for swapping to 20/22mm straps.lug opening is 18 millim which is a little thin for my wrist sizeWatch from 4:42
Hardlex crystal disappoints at this price3 of 7
- WatchChris Believes sapphire would be better than Hardlex for an everyday watch.it's the sapphire crystal that beats the hardlex crystalWatch from 3:19
- WatchChris Sees the Hardlex crystal as the hardest aspect to accept at this price.it's probably the hardlex crystal which is the hardest pill to swallow for mostWatch from 10:02
- Ben's Watch Club Keeping Hardlex rather than sapphire is poor when rivals at this price use sapphire.the upper tier Sapphire used by almost all brands in this price bracketWatch from 7:43
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Worries the domed Hardlex crystal is more exposed and may get scratched.you could end up scratching it over timeWatch from 4:42
Domed crystal distorts and hurts legibility3 of 7
- YoureTerrific Acknowledges the domed crystal somewhat reduces legibility.it it actually kind of hurts the legibilityWatch from 3:52
- Average Bros Would have preferred a dual-curve crystal over the single-curve Hardlex, which distorts at angles.I personally would have preferred if it was a dual curveWatch from 3:24
- Ben's Watch Club Domed crystal with poor or no anti-reflective coating reduces legibility.it reduces legibility too as these crystals have either poor or just no anti-reflective coatingWatch from 8:12
Price has climbed steeply over predecessors3 of 7
- WatchChris Feels the price is fairly high for what it is.it does seem like it's pretty expensiveWatch from 9:05
- ANACHRONIST Finds the price jump from the original a sticker shock.at $400 this is a bit of a sticker shock compared to the originalWatch from 4:20
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Laments that Seiko prices have climbed compared with years ago.I know I know Seiko pricing I would love to see the pricesWatch from 5:38
Newer Seiko 5 logo spoils the dial2 of 7
- YoureTerrific Dislikes the newer Seiko 5 logo, preferring the old shield.I still don't like this newer logoWatch from 6:47
- WatchChris Would prefer the Seiko 5 logo removed from the dial.I wish they wouldn't put that five on the dialWatch from 4:45

Show 3 more

Small recessed crown awkward to wind2 of 7
- ANACHRONIST Finds hand-winding via the small recessed crown not pleasant.not that winding that tiny recess Crown is a pleasureWatch from 5:45
- TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces Finds the recessed crown too small and hard to wind.it's just a tad too small for my fingersWatch from 3:18
Design feels muted and less engaging2 of 7
- ANACHRONIST Over a week, found it less interesting and kept reaching for the old model instead.noticed myself grabbing the old SN XS more and moreWatch from 7:09
- Ben's Watch Club Found it flat and dull on first impression, more muted than the original.to me the srpk just looked a bit flat a bit dullWatch from 4:49
- Ben's Watch Club Concludes the overall result is somewhat dull and boring.silene more towards the opinion that the final result is a little dull and boringWatch from 11:08
Domed crystal makes the watch look chunky1 of 7
- Ben's Watch Club Feels the domed crystal gives an unsuitable bulbous, inflated look.doesn't quite suit the resultant bulbous almost inflated lookWatch from 8:12
- Ben's Watch Club Domed crystal adds thickness, making it stubbier and chunkier than necessary.it feel stubbier and chunkier than it probably couldWatch from 8:42

Open a point to see who said it and jump to that moment in their review.

By aspect

PositiveMixedNegative

How reviewers judged each aspect; one square per reviewer who discussed it
Design		Praised
Dial		Praised
Case & proportions		Mostly liked
Bracelet & strap		Mostly liked
Value		Mixed
Wearability		Praised
Finishing & build		Praised
Movement		Mostly liked
Versatility		Praised
Originality		Praised
Functionality		Praised

Was this consensus useful?

The reviews

7 counted

Remontoir summarises; the reviewers did the work. Watch and read the originals for the full picture.

Average Bros

Seiko 5 Sports 'SNXS Series' – SRPL59, A Low-Key Classic Flying under the Radar for around $350!

Video, 18 minHands-on reviewDec 2025

Very positiveRecommends

Sees this SNXS variant as an underhyped, versatile everyday watch with a warm gold dial, strong detailing and a solid bracelet at a great price. Minor quibbles are the single-curve Hardlex, the 18mm lug width and slightly small size on a larger wrist.

Suits: Smaller wrists, or larger wrists with vintage-size tastes; casual heritage buyers

What they said, point by point

Dialpositive: Finds the golden dial fantastic, with a warm tone and a nice pop. 2:25
Praises the polished, well-lumed applied indices as feeling pricier than the watch is. 5:48
Calls the handset fantastic, finely detailed and well executed. 7:43
Finds the lume brighter than expected for a dressier watch. 13:24
Case & proportionsmixed: Would have preferred a dual-curve crystal over the single-curve Hardlex, which distorts at angles. 3:24
Finds the small push-pull crown workable for hand winding and visually symmetrical. 4:22
Admires the chamfered case and lug transitions. 8:11
Bracelet & strappositive: Wishes the lug width were 19 or 20mm; 18mm with heavy taper feels small. 8:11
Notes solid links and end links, a big improvement over the older hollow SNXS bracelets. 8:38
Clasp is stamped rather than milled, but the flexible bracelet is comfortable. 9:35
Thinks the three-link bracelet looks like something bought aftermarket. 12:55
Wearabilitypositive: Finds it handsome and well proportioned on the wrist. 10:02
Feels a little small on the reviewer's larger wrist, suiting long-sleeve wear. 10:30
Considers the 12.7mm thickness noteworthy but not a deal breaker. 12:25
Movementmixed: Notes the 41-hour power reserve is more limited than Seiko's 6R calibres. 4:50
Has had few issues with 4R movements and notes some consider them more stable. 5:20
Finishing & buildpositive: Praises the fine transitions between satin brushing and high polish. 13:52
Likes the precisely aligned sloped chapter ring. 3:24
Designpositive: Finds this variant more versatile and less funky than the first three revival models. 2:25
Likes the retro gold tone that stays understated. 14:19
Versatilitypositive: Imagines it dressed up on a glossy black exotic leather strap. 14:48
Can be worn casually on the bracelet when not dressed up. 14:48
Valuepositive: Calls the discounted retailer price a great deal. 0:59
Thinks few rivals can beat it at the price. 15:17
Originalitypositive: Appreciates that it comes from the brand that created the look, unlike homages. 15:46

Watch on YouTube

YoureTerrific

The Seiko 5 is so back

Video, 9 minHands-on reviewNov 2025

Very positiveRecommends

Charmed by the new 37mm Seiko 5 SNXS revival: its size, vintage styling and dial work well together. The reviewer sees big upgrades over the old SNXS and considers $415 worth it despite minor flaws like hand blemishes, a stamped clasp and an unremarkable movement.

Suits: Fans of the classic, vintage-sized Seiko 5 look

Disclosure: Retailer stock

What they said, point by point

Designpositive: Feels the throwback crystal and small size combine very effectively. 3:52
Notes it looks vintage by design but does not feel like an old watch. 3:52
Case & proportionspositive: Calls the 37.4mm size perfect on a 7-inch wrist for this style. 3:24
Acknowledges the domed crystal somewhat reduces legibility. 3:52
Wearabilitypositive: Finds it comfortable on a 7-inch wrist. 4:50
Dialpositive: Likes the contrasting chapter ring and the orange seconds hand. 6:18
Dislikes the newer Seiko 5 logo, preferring the old shield. 6:47
Appreciates the restrained text at 6 o'clock. 6:47
Finds the lume bright but not long-lasting. 7:16
Bracelet & strapmixed: Praises solid links, solid end links and good tolerances. 4:50
Finds the stamped clasp not especially nice, though it offers two micro-adjustments. 4:50
Movementmixed: Notes the movement is plain-looking and often not very accurate. 5:20
Considers the 41-hour power reserve merely acceptable. 5:20
Sees hacking and hand-winding as the biggest improvement. 5:20
Functionalitypositive: Says 100m water resistance is all most people need. 6:18
Finishing & buildmixed: Points out blemishes on the hands and a white spot near 8 o'clock. 7:16
Valuepositive: Personally judges the $415 price worthwhile. 7:16
Adores the watches at this price and is considering buying one. 7:44
Justifies the price increase through inflation and substantial upgrades. 8:13
Compared with: Seiko 5 SNXS (pre-2019 generation): New version fixes jangly bracelet, non-hand-winding movement and poor water resistance.
Seiko 5 SRPL (SNXS series): SRPL is dressier, lacking the contrasting chapter ring and orange seconds hand.

Watch on YouTube

Ben's Watch Club

Does Seiko Think We're Stupid? - New "SNXS" Is...Confusing.

Video, 13 minHands-on reviewJul 2024

MixedRecommends, with caveats

The reviewer finds the reissued SNXS a well-made watch that fixes the original's case, movement and water resistance. However, the dull design, domed Hardlex crystal, semi-folded bracelet links and much higher price leave the reviewer apathetic. It is only a no-brainer if found under about $200.

Suits: Buyers wanting a low-key, safe everyday design, ideally at a discount

Disclosure: Reviewer owns it

What they said, point by point

Designmixed: Found it flat and dull on first impression, more muted than the original. 4:49
Notes the reviewer's wife liked its retro, sporty look. 4:49
Concludes the overall result is somewhat dull and boring. 11:08
Feels the domed crystal gives an unsuitable bulbous, inflated look. 8:12
Dialmixed: Macro footage shows better-cut hands and cleaner markers. 10:38
Struggles to find anything giving the dial a meaningful advantage over the predecessor. 10:09
Domed crystal with poor or no anti-reflective coating reduces legibility. 8:12
Case & proportionspositive: Case shape is far better tailored than the original, with taller sides and curved lugs. 5:18
Mostly brushed finish is predictable but a major step up, plus drilled lugs and an easy crown cutout. 6:17
Thinks 20mm lugs would suit better, as the 18mm band looks swallowed up. 6:45
Domed crystal adds thickness, making it stubbier and chunkier than necessary. 8:42
Wearabilitypositive: The new case shape makes it wear much better on the wrist. 5:18
Compact, but the wide stance makes it appear larger, so it also suits bigger wrists. 5:48
Bracelet & strapnegative: Links are only partially solid, which is disappointing versus microbrands at this price. 7:15
Clasp offers only two micro-adjustment holes, roughly half a link of range. 7:15
End links are not very flush but are serviceable. 6:45
Movementpositive: Considers the 4R36 reliable and nicer-looking than the old movement. 9:12
Values the addition of hacking and hand winding. 9:12
Functionalitypositive: The 10 bar rating gives performance matching its sporty aesthetic. 9:41
Versatilitypositive: Subdued matte design invites everyday, multi-purpose use. 11:08
Originalitymixed: Finds it more ethical since it is no longer a blatant Rolex copy. 10:09
Raised chapter ring and orange seconds hand add some individuality. 10:09
Still clearly derived from the Oyster Perpetual. 10:09
Valuenegative: Keeping Hardlex rather than sapphire is poor when rivals at this price use sapphire. 7:43
Sees the domed crystal as a cheap token feature to justify the higher price. 8:42
Would choose more exciting dials at this price. 11:37
Would be a no-brainer if bought for around or under $200, and resale is strong. 12:06
Compared with: Seiko 5 SNXS77 (original SNXS): Improves the case, movement and water resistance, but costs roughly triple.
Rolex Oyster Perpetual: Still Oyster-inspired but less of a blatant clone than the original.

Watch on YouTube

WatchChris

The New Seiko SNXS - Are Seiko Watches Still Worth the Money? Featuring the Seiko 5 Sports SRPK89.

Video, 12 minHands-on reviewJun 2024

PositiveRecommends, with caveats

The reviewer finds the SRPK89 a handsome, well-finished, vintage-flavoured 37mm watch with excellent lume and a solid bracelet. The Hardlex crystal and $395 price are the main drawbacks, but it is considered worth the money for Seiko fans who can accept Hardlex.

Suits: Seiko fans wanting an affordable, versatile vacation or everyday watch

Disclosure: Retailer stock

What they said, point by point

Dialpositive: Likes how the black dial pairs with the creamy lume. 1:54
Enjoys the orange seconds hand for its vintage feel. 2:22
Would prefer the Seiko 5 logo removed from the dial. 4:45
Finds the lume excellent and long-lasting, though wants lume on the seconds hand. 9:33
Designpositive: Likes the simplicity and overall colour combination. 8:07
Case & proportionsmixed: Wears like a vintage-sized watch while feeling modern. 2:22
Thinks the thin polished bezel works well and makes it look bigger. 5:41
Believes sapphire would be better than Hardlex for an everyday watch. 3:19
Finishing & buildpositive: Finds the case finishing as good as Seiko's pricier non-5 models. 5:13
Bracelet & strappositive: Appreciates the solid links and end links. 2:22
Finds the pressed clasp nicer than expected. 2:22
Wishes for more micro-adjust positions; notes no half links. 6:09
Versatilitypositive: Suitable both dressed up and for swimming. 5:41
Considers it a great vacation watch. 6:09
Valuemixed: Feels the price is fairly high for what it is. 9:05
Sees the Hardlex crystal as the hardest aspect to accept at this price. 10:02
Still judges it worth the money if Hardlex is acceptable. 9:05
Originalitypositive: Sees Seiko's history and iconic status as a reason to buy it. 10:31
Compared with: Islander Greenport ISL 252: Islander offers more for the money, with comparable finishing but less heritage.

Watch on YouTube

TimeToGo Travel And Timepieces

Seiko 5 SNXS Series - Hands on With All Three! SRPK87 SRPK89 SRPK91

Video, 6 minHands-on reviewJun 2024

PositiveRecommends, with caveats

A fan of the SNXS reissue, praising its improved case finishing, legible dial and colourways. Reservations include a small, hard-to-wind crown, a stamped clasp, narrow 18mm lugs and Seiko's rising prices; the size is personally a bit small.

Suits: Beginners getting into watches, or seasoned collectors who like the style

Disclosure: Retailer stock

What they said, point by point

Designpositive: Likes the black, finds the blue sportier, and sees the tan as more unique. 0:55
Considers the tan version distinctive and appealing. 0:55
Dialpositive: Likes how the contrasting chapter ring frames the dial. 1:24
Finds the polished and brushed hands easy to read in any lighting. 1:53
Thinks the orange seconds hand suits every colourway and accepts that it lacks lume. 1:53
Prefers white lume to faux patina but feels it works with these colour combinations. 2:21
Case & proportionsmixed: Sees the case as a clear improvement in finish over the older SNXS models. 2:50
Finds the recessed crown too small and hard to wind. 3:18
Worries the domed Hardlex crystal is more exposed and may get scratched. 4:42
Wearabilitymixed: Says it wears comfortably. 2:50
Notes it is fairly heavy for a small watch. 2:50
Finds it smaller than personal preference but still likes the look on the wrist. 5:09
Bracelet & strapmixed: Rates the bracelet as okay and better than the older versions, with solid end links. 3:47
Criticises the stamped-steel clasp, which has only two micro-adjustment positions. 4:16
Finds the 18mm lug width narrow and inconvenient for swapping to 20/22mm straps. 4:42
Appreciates the drilled lugs for easier strap changes. 2:50
Finishing & buildpositive: Considers the finishing good for the price point. 2:50
Valuemixed: Laments that Seiko prices have climbed compared with years ago. 5:38
Compared with: Seiko 5 SNXS (original series, e.g. SNXS79): The new case finishing and bracelet are better than on the older models.

Watch on YouTube

ANACHRONIST

Did Seiko Improve their BEST VALUED Watch?

Video, 8 minComparisonMay 2024

Positive

Considers the new SRPK an objectively better, more complete watch than the old SNXS. It has sharper case finishing, a solid-link bracelet, hacking and hand-winding, 100m WR and better comfort. Yet the reviewer found it less interesting and kept reaching for the quirkier original. The $400 price is a noted jump.

Suits: Those wanting a versatile, comfortable go-anywhere daily watch in a smaller size

Disclosure: Reviewer owns it

What they said, point by point

Case & proportionspositive: Glad Seiko kept a smaller case size instead of going to 40mm. 4:20
Despite being thicker, the curved, organic case shape helps it sit better on the wrist. 5:16
Finds the 44.5mm lug-to-lug keeps it subtle. 5:16
Notes it still uses Hardlex rather than sapphire, expecting complaints. 4:48
Finishing & buildpositive: Sees the case finishing as a major improvement made with more precise machining. 4:48
Praises sharp lines and brushed/polished transitions, likening them to Longines-level finishing. 4:48
Bracelet & strappositive: Welcomes the move to solid links. 5:16
Clasp remains stamped but gains a twin-trigger release for a more secure lock. 5:16
Finds the bracelet feels heftier and more durable. 5:16
Movementpositive: Appreciates the addition of hacking and hand-winding. 5:45
Notes the 4R36 brings no gain in accuracy or power reserve. 5:45
Finds hand-winding via the small recessed crown not pleasant. 5:45
Dialpositive: Finds the faux patina on the markers subtle and pleasing. 5:45
Sees the chapter ring and orange seconds as making the dial more playful. 6:13
Designmixed: Likes that it takes itself less seriously than the old watch. 6:13
Considers it a more complete package overall. 6:13
Over a week, found it less interesting and kept reaching for the old model instead. 7:09
Wearabilitypositive: Finds the bracelet and case no longer shake or wobble on the wrist. 6:13
Describes it as comfortable for all-day wear. 6:13
Versatilitypositive: Considers it a go-anywhere watch compared with the sterner old model. 6:13
Functionalitypositive: Values the significant water resistance upgrade to 100m. 6:42
Valuemixed: Finds the price jump from the original a sticker shock. 4:20
Acknowledges $400 is not excessive for a watch nowadays. 4:20
Compared with: Seiko 5 SNXS (7S26, previous generation): New one better on paper and comfort; old one more charming and worn more.

Watch on YouTube

Long Island Watch

Why Seiko's new release is GENIUS

Video, 9 minHands-on reviewMay 2024

Very positiveRecommends

Sees the 4R36 SNXS re-release as a big quality step up from older budget Seikos, praising its solid feel, polishing, bracelet and classy vintage look. Acknowledges the $395 price will draw complaints but defends it as a beautiful, well-made watch.

Suits: People with smaller wrists wanting a classy, vintage-style everyday watch

Disclosure: Retailer stock

What they said, point by point

Finishing & buildpositive: Says it feels much better in the hand than the older SNKL, which now feels cheap by comparison. 3:17
Praises the case polishing. 3:46
Bracelet & strappositive: Likes the solid-link construction and clasp. 2:49
Considers the bracelet so good an aftermarket replacement may be unnecessary. 3:17
Notes one fewer micro-adjust position than the older model; clasp unremarkable. 4:45
Wearabilitypositive: Finds the weight distribution excellent. 2:49
Recommends it for people with smaller wrists. 8:09
Dialpositive: Likes the dial colour even if the sunray isn't bright. 5:15
Enjoys the orange seconds hand as a colour accent. 5:45
Finds it easy to read. 7:42
Points out no lume on the seconds hand and no lume pip near the day-date. 7:42
Designpositive: Describes the watch as very classy and good-looking. 4:45
Finds the vintage look suits the 37mm size. 7:12
Thinks it looks well proportioned on the wrist, with nice chaptering. 8:37
Case & proportionspositive: Crown is less recessed than on the old model but still well tucked in. 4:16
Valuemixed: Anticipates complaints about the $395 retail but still calls it beautiful. 5:15
Expects strong sales at full retail. 5:15
Defends price against cheaper rivals by noting Seiko's in-house design and development. 6:43
Originalitypositive: Sees Seiko officially adopting the community's SNXS name as a smart, important move. 1:26
Compared with: Seiko 5 SNKL23: Older SNKL feels cheap and tiny; new SNXS heavier and more solid.
Seiko 5 SNXS (original 7S26): New dial printing is a little fancier than the old block print.

Watch on YouTube

Specifications

Reference: SRPK89K1
Case: 37.4mm, stainless steel
Thickness: 12.5mm
Lug to lug: 44.7mm
Movement: Seiko 4R36 (automatic)
Power reserve: 41 hours
Water resistance: 100m
Crystal: curved Hardlex
Bracelet or strap: stainless steel bracelet with three-fold push-button clasp, 18mm lugs
Announced: April 2024
List price (US): $395US list price $395 on seikowatches.com at launch (Wayback, June-Dec 2024)

Creator Consensus is built only from what reviewers said. Prices, retailers and any commercial relationship never affect it. How consensus works