Each marker on the ring is one counted review, coloured by its verdict.

Tudor

Black Bay

M7941A1A0NU-000141mmautomatic$4,435 list priceAnnounced April 2024

The 2024 all-black version of Tudor's third-generation 41mm Black Bay diver, with a black aluminium bezel and a dial that drops the gilt accents and red triangle for silver-white markings. It uses the slimmer 13.6mm case introduced in 2023 and the Master Chronometer-certified MT5602-U movement.

Tudor product page

Creator Consensus

Positive

8 reviews: 8 positive, 0 mixed, 0 negative. 8 of 8 recommend it.

Every reviewer recommends this Black Bay. Nearly all single out the T-fit clasp as easy to use and class-leading, and most say the monochrome, gilt-free execution works well and that the watch sits comfortably on the wrist. Several credit the Master Chronometer calibre with raising the standard and consider it fair value for the quality delivered.

Where they differ. Several reviewers find it derivative and hard to distinguish from other divers, though one sees it as a modern preservation rather than a throwback. On the case, some say the slimmer profile fixes a longstanding flaw, while some others feel it still looks tall and thick.

Most praised

T-fit clasp is easy and class-leading7 of 8
- aBlogtoWatch Calls the straps great and values the T-Fit adjustment for fitting any wrist.The straps are great and all three have the T-Fit mechanismRead it in context
- Monochrome Finds the T-fit micro-adjustment clasp practical.this practical micro-adjustment system allows wearers to carry out a fine, instant adjustmentRead it in context
- Fratello The T-fit clasp closes with a satisfying, secure click.after closing the clasp with a reassuring clickRead it in context
- Teddy Baldassarre Calls the T-fit tool-free micro-adjustment class-leading and easy to size.making sizing a breezeWatch from 4:21
- Adrian Barker Rates the T-fit clasp extension system as one of the best, and the clasp as good-looking.this is honestly one of the best bracelet extension systems. I love it.Watch from 4:41
- Bruce Williams Praises the easy-to-use T-fit clasp and its generous adjustment range.I like the adjustability of this clasp. The T-fit system is easy to use.Watch from 2:51
- The Watch Idiot Considers the T-fit the best on-the-fly adjustment clasp, above Rolex's Glidelock.it's so easy to use it feels secureWatch from 3:19
Monochrome execution without gilt works well6 of 8
- aBlogtoWatch Sees the grey-scale colourway as an unfussy, sedate alternative to gilt or blue-black versions.a simple gray-scale colorway that offers an unfussy, sedate optionRead it in context
- aBlogtoWatch Considers removing colour potentially more impactful than adding a new one.seems perhaps more impactful than adding a new colorRead it in context
- aBlogtoWatch Enjoys the plain monochrome execution.just simple gray-scale goodnessRead it in context
- Fratello Feels better than collection peers that use fake gold accents.the watch feels a lot better than its peers in the collection that have fake gold accentsRead it in context
- The Deep Track Believes the design suits the stark monochrome contrast perfectly.the design works perfectly well rendered in such stark contrastRead it in context
- The Deep Track Thinks dropping gilt lets the design choices be appreciated on their own terms.this execution offers a chance to fully appreciate these design choicesRead it in context
- The Watch Idiot Values the complete absence of gilt or colour accents.there is zero color on this watchWatch from 0:56
- Bruce Williams Finds the monochrome scheme attractive though safe and conservative.It's a very attractive, very safe or conservative style or color scheme.Watch from 0:00
- Teddy Baldassarre Highlights the high contrast of the pure black and white execution.white and black serving up high contrastWatch from 4:50
Sits comfortably and naturally on the wrist5 of 8
- aBlogtoWatch Says the 41mm Black Bay sits excellently on the wrist.it sits brilliantly on the wristRead it in context
- Monochrome Describes the wearing experience as pleasant.but it offers a pleasant rideRead it in context
- Fratello Finds the 41mm size perfect on the wrist.the 41mm size feels perfectRead it in context
- Fratello Felt right on the wrist throughout days of wear.it just felt right on my wristRead it in context
- Fratello Sits comfortably and naturally on the wrist.the watch feels right at home on the wristRead it in context
- The Deep Track Considers the new case perfectly wearable and pleasant on the wrist.overall this is a very pleasant watch on the wristRead it in context
- Bruce Williams Likes the size and how it fits on the wrist.I like the size. I like the fit on my wrist.Watch from 2:23
Master Chronometer calibre raises the standard4 of 8
- Monochrome Highlights that the movement now carries one of the toughest certifications on the market.now it comes with one of the most demanding certifications on the marketRead it in context
- Fratello Views Master Chronometer certification as raising Tudor's movement standard.Tudor took a great step in upping the standard for its movementsRead it in context
- Bruce Williams Enjoys the independently certified in-house movement and finds it robust.I also really enjoy this manufacture Tudor movementWatch from 3:19
- Teddy Baldassarre Considers the MT5602-U's specifications class-leading for its price point.providing class leading specifications and Technical upgrades for the price pointWatch from 6:47
- Teddy Baldassarre Credits the upgraded calibre as part of why the watch delivers for collectors.with its up specification caliber and subtle design updatesWatch from 9:41
Fair price for the quality delivered4 of 8
- Monochrome Considers the price fair given its quality and features, which is rare in the current market.superb quality and advanced technical features at a price that still seems fairRead it in context
- Fratello Considers it the best choice available at its price.for just over €4.5K new, I couldn’t think of a better pickRead it in context
- The Deep Track Cannot imagine a better single dive watch under $5,000.I cannot imagine a better candidate under $5,000 than this Black Bay 41Read it in context
- Bruce Williams Considers it a luxury watch at a reasonable price that delivers a lot for the money.This is currently what I would consider a solid luxury value.Watch from 0:56
- Fratello Cheaper than vintage Tudor Subs and a far better watch.what you get in return is a far better watchRead it in context
Closest modern take on the classic Tudor Submariner3 of 8
- Teddy Baldassarre Calls it the closest thing yet to a faithful Tudor Submariner revival.the closest thing we've ever gotten to a faithful cover of a track that we all lovedWatch from 8:42
- Fratello Sees it as the closest modern equivalent to a classic Tudor Submariner.probably the closest you can get to a classic Tudor SubRead it in context
- The Watch Idiot Sees it as the first modern Black Bay in the most classic colour combination.it's finally a modern take on the black Bay in the most classic collar comboWatch from 1:25

Show 19 more

Wears better than earlier 41mm Black Bays3 of 8
- Teddy Baldassarre Urges people to try it on, as it wears completely differently from earlier, larger-wearing 41mm Black Bays.please know that they wear it completely differentlyWatch from 2:55
- The Deep Track Says recent changes nudged the watch inside the reviewer's comfort zone.nudging the watch just inside of my, and I surmise many others’, comfort zoneRead it in context
- Fratello Sees the optimized case dimensions as removing the chunkiness of other Tudor models.optimizing the case dimensions immediately cleans up the different Tudor modelsRead it in context
Bracelet is excellent and well suited3 of 8
- Adrian Barker Calls the bracelet incredible and among the best from any brand.The bracelet is incredible.Watch from 4:12
- The Watch Idiot Finds the bracelet silky, smooth, and excellent.the bracelet itself is fantastic the links are silkyWatch from 2:51
- Fratello Considers the Oyster-style bracelet the right choice for this black version.the Oyster-style bracelet was the only right option for this newRead it in context
Solid build and outstanding overall quality3 of 8
- Monochrome Credits Tudor with delivering superb quality.Tudor is doing an impressive job in delivering superb qualityRead it in context
- Fratello Feels more solid than most watches tested at a similar price.not many feel as sturdy and solid as this Tudor, especially at a similar price pointRead it in context
- Fratello No rattle anywhere thanks to precise tolerances.a total absence of rattly elements because the tolerances are spot onRead it in context
- Fratello Rates overall quality as outstanding.The overall quality of these watches is outstanding.Read it in context
- The Watch Idiot Feels high quality in the hand and on the wrist.when you you hold the watch and you wear it it exudes qualityWatch from 2:22
Bezel action is superb and precise3 of 8
- Adrian Barker Praises the bezel action.It's still got the great bezel action that it has.Watch from 0:00
- Bruce Williams Rates the bezel's tactile action best or near-best in its class.This has the best tactile bezel action in its class or near its class.Watch from 2:51
- The Watch Idiot Calls it the best 60-click bezel ever used: perfectly weighted with crisp clicks.it is still the best sixa click bezel I've ever usedWatch from 3:49
Bezel and crown are easy to grip3 of 8
- Adrian Barker Bezel overhang is seen as useful for grip.so it overhangs ever so slightly, but that's what allows you to get the gripWatch from 4:12
- The Watch Idiot The chunkier bezel teeth make turning easier than on the BB58.enough to make turning the bezel even easier than on black p 58Watch from 4:18
- Teddy Baldassarre Considers the redesigned grooved crown, echoed on the bezel edge, the standout change and easier to grip.redesign crown with larger reflective grooves that are mirrored on the bezel EdgeWatch from 3:23
Ideal daily or one-watch collection3 of 8
- Fratello Calls it the perfect pick for a daily wearer under €5K.the perfect pick if you are looking for the best daily wearerRead it in context
- Bruce Williams Considers it an excellent daily wear watch.I personally think it is a heck of a daily wear watchWatch from 0:29
- Adrian Barker Calls it an ideal first and daily watch to build a collection around.an ideal first watch, an ideal daily watchWatch from 8:00
- Adrian Barker Suggests it could be a one-watch collection despite scepticism of the concept.I I feel like this could be itWatch from 8:00
Timeless design that should age well2 of 8
- Monochrome Believes the design will still look purposeful for many years.one that will still look purposeful many years from nowRead it in context
- The Deep Track Finds the dial old-school in a timeless way.It all feels old-school in a timeless wayRead it in context
Preferable on the wrist to the BB58 and BB542 of 8
- aBlogtoWatch Prefers wearing it over the Black Bay 58 and 54.I actually prefer it to the 58 and the 54.Read it in context
- The Watch Idiot The curved caseback teeth make it more comfortable than the BB58 and BB54.which makes it much more comfortable on the wristWatch from 2:22
Slimmer case profile fixes a longstanding flaw2 of 8
- Monochrome Sees the reduced thickness as fixing one of the model's main flaws.Tudor corrected one of the main flaws of the BB, its thickness.Read it in context
- Monochrome Likes how thinner flanks and a domed caseback make the case look slimmer.The thinner measurement is thus visually reinforced by this design trickRead it in context
- Adrian Barker Explains the domed crystal lets the case itself be slightly slimmer.shaving off a little bit of the depth of the caseWatch from 5:11
Ceramic clasp components built for durability2 of 8
- Monochrome Sees the ceramic ball bearings in the clasp as a sign of commitment to durability.a small detail that shows the brand’s dedication to durabilityRead it in context
- Teddy Baldassarre Appreciates ceramic pins in the clasp to resist long-term wear.ceramic pins to effectively take on any wear and tearWatch from 3:52
Crisp brushed and polished finishing details2 of 8
- Teddy Baldassarre Says finishing details elevate the presentation and add modern aesthetics.finishing has several points of interest that haveWatch from 2:55
- The Watch Idiot Transitions between brushed and polished surfaces are sharp and consistent.the transitions between polished and brushed on the case are sharpWatch from 3:19
Anti-magnetism offers genuine real-world value2 of 8
- Adrian Barker Sees METAS certification as meaning the watch can handle daily life without care.The reality is it just means that this watch can handle life. It doesn't need to be babyed.Watch from 7:31
- Adrian Barker Believes METAS proof of antimagnetism and temperature resilience has real worth.This movement doesn't get interrupted by temperature changes. So it is worth something.Watch from 7:03
- The Watch Idiot Anti-magnetism is increasingly practical with magnets everywhere, giving peace of mind when travelling.truly anti-magnetic to like a ridiculous degree it gives me peace of mindWatch from 5:46
Accurate and consistent in daily use2 of 8
- Bruce Williams Trusts it to keep consistent time through almost any activity.going to keep consistent time and look goodWatch from 3:49
- The Watch Idiot Proven accurate in the reviewer's own testing.it's proven to be accurate after many tests is greatWatch from 4:47
Strong, crisp lume and white indices2 of 8
- Bruce Williams Finds the lume very strong and long-lasting.This has very potent, long-lasting loom.Watch from 2:51
- The Watch Idiot Likes the crisp white indices and lume.now has crisp white indices and LoomWatch from 1:25
Distinctive handset nods to older references2 of 8
- The Deep Track Likes the new lollipop seconds hand as a nod to older references.providing a nice nod to older referencesRead it in context
- Bruce Williams Loves the distinctive snowflake hour hand, finding it legible and preferring it to Mercedes hands.I think the snowflake hand here on the hour hand is beautiful.Watch from 4:18
Colourway pairs with almost any strap2 of 8
- aBlogtoWatch Believes the colourway pairs well with almost any aftermarket strap.the colorway should allow for a great pairing with just about any strap you haveRead it in context
- aBlogtoWatch Suggests the lack of colour could make it the most versatile Black Bay yet.which may make it the most versatile Black Bay yetRead it in context
- Bruce Williams Finds the colour scheme versatile enough to work on any strap.you couldn't put a bad strap on this watchWatch from 4:18
Holds up well against the pricier Submariner2 of 8
- The Deep Track Doubts in-hand differences justify the Submariner's much higher price.I’m not sure they will account for the gulf in priceRead it in context
- Monochrome Sees it as more than just a cheaper Submariner alternative.it’s becoming more than just an alternativeRead it in context
Lug design flows naturally into bracelet1 of 8
- The Deep Track Credits the 21mm lug width with creating a more natural flow into the bracelet.allows for a more natural flow between the width of the caseRead it in context
- The Deep Track Welcomes the polished chamfer along the lug edge as a transition.a polished chamfer runs the edge of the lug in a welcome bit of transitionRead it in context
A modern preservation rather than a throwback1 of 8
- The Deep Track Sees it as a modern preservation rather than a mere throwback.this watch is more than just a throwback, it’s a modern preservationRead it in context
- The Deep Track Feels the watch marks a turning point for the collection.it feels like a turning point for the collectionRead it in context

Most criticised

Derivative and hard to distinguish from other divers4 of 8
- Monochrome Concedes it is probably not the most striking or original design.probably not the most striking or originalRead it in context
- Teddy Baldassarre Says the world does not need another black-and-white Submariner-inspired diver.watch that takes strong points of design inspiration from the Submariner absolutely notWatch from 9:11
- Teddy Baldassarre Acknowledges that in isolation it reads as derivative.in a vacuum this watch delivers on all the signs youWatch from 9:11
- Adrian Barker Considers it a generic black-bezel, black-dial diver among countless others.it's just another black bezel, black dialed dive watch, and there's a million of thoseWatch from 0:49
- The Watch Idiot Lacks distinctiveness in a collection of similar divers, so it rarely got worn.amongst all my divers it struggles to stand out in a wayWatch from 6:44
- Adrian Barker Notes it is not really new, only a colour variation of last year's model.This watch isn't even new. It's just a color change.Watch from 0:49
Case still looks tall and thick2 of 8
- The Deep Track Notes the case thickness remains very visible from the side.the rest is still very much visible when viewed from the sideRead it in context
- Bruce Williams Finds the case borderline too tall, though not a deal breaker.it's borderline too tallWatch from 5:16
- Bruce Williams Feels the mid-case is thick and chunky proportionally.the mid-case feels a bit thick. It feels a bit chunkyWatch from 5:16
- Bruce Williams Says it lacks the proportional refinement of a Rolex Submariner.this does not have the refinement that you would find on say a Rolex SubmarinerWatch from 5:46
Polished clasp centre scratches easily2 of 8
- Teddy Baldassarre Warns the polished centre of the clasp will scratch more easily than before.Polish Center portion that will be much more suceptible to scratchesWatch from 3:52
- The Watch Idiot The polished clasp centre picks up hairline scratches easily.the center of the clasp is polished and it's a scratch magnetWatch from 8:39
Faux rivets on bracelet feel overdone2 of 8
- Adrian Barker In the intro, jokingly dismisses the riveted bracelet as horrible.It's still got the horrible rivet braceletWatch from 0:00
- Bruce Williams Considers the faux rivets on the stepped bracelet over the top.I think the faux rivets are just a little bit over the top.Watch from 5:46
Bezel edge too slim and understated2 of 8
- The Deep Track Finds the thin, tight bezel edge difficult to grab and turn.It’s quite difficult to grab and manipulateRead it in context
- Fratello After a week, found the bezel not pronounced enough for personal taste.As it turns out, I like a more pronounced bezel.Read it in context
Losing gilt removes some character1 of 8
- Adrian Barker Feels losing the gilt and red triangle removes some of the watch's character.So I feel like some of the character is missing.Watch from 2:17

Show 4 more

Long lugs may overhang smaller wrists1 of 8
- The Deep Track Warns that the long lugs may overhang on some wrists.the long lug creating some overhang on some wristsRead it in context
Bracelet feel falls short of Rolex1 of 8
- The Deep Track Finds the female end link and connector articulate well but feel loose.can feel a little loosey goosey in practiceRead it in context
- The Deep Track Sees the bracelet feel as the biggest in-hand sign of the price gap to a Submariner.the biggest in-hand tell that there is a considerable price differenceRead it in context
Weak anti-reflective coating causes glare1 of 8
- Bruce Williams Says anti-reflective coating is very poor, causing annoying reflections outdoors; nearly a deal breaker.I consider it almost a deal breakerWatch from 5:16
Rising prices and allocation erode value1 of 8
- Bruce Williams Feels each price increase makes it less of a value proposition.the more Tudor does price increases, the less of a luxury value I find this to beWatch from 1:24
- Bruce Williams Finds Tudor's adoption of Rolex-style restricted allocation disappointing.And that's a bit disappointing, I think.Watch from 6:43

Open a point to see who said it and jump to that moment in their review.

By aspect

PositiveMixedNegative

How reviewers judged each aspect; one square per reviewer who discussed it
Design		Praised
Bracelet & strap		Mostly liked
Wearability		Praised
Case & proportions		Praised
Movement		Praised
Originality		Divided
Versatility		Praised
Dial		Praised
Finishing & build		Praised
Functionality		Praised
Value		Praised

Was this consensus useful?

The reviews

8 counted

Remontoir summarises; the reviewers did the work. Watch and read the originals for the full picture.

Bruce Williams

Tudor Black Bay Perfection? Where do they go from here? Monochrome Review

Video, 9 minHands-on reviewOct 2025

PositiveRecommends, with caveats

Sees the Black Bay 41 Monochrome as an excellent, versatile daily wearer and a solid luxury value, praising lume, bezel action, the METAS movement and snowflake hand. Criticises the weak anti-reflective coating, slightly chunky case, faux-rivet bracelet and Tudor's rising prices.

Suits: Collectors seeking a robust, versatile everyday luxury dive watch

Disclosure: Retailer stock

What they said, point by point

Valuemixed: Considers it a luxury watch at a reasonable price that delivers a lot for the money. 0:56
Feels each price increase makes it less of a value proposition. 1:24
Finds Tudor's adoption of Rolex-style restricted allocation disappointing. 6:43
Wearabilitypositive: Likes the size and how it fits on the wrist. 2:23
Notes it wears smaller than the stated 41mm, similar to a 41mm Submariner. 2:23
Case & proportionsmixed: Finds the case borderline too tall, though not a deal breaker. 5:16
Feels the mid-case is thick and chunky proportionally. 5:16
Says it lacks the proportional refinement of a Rolex Submariner. 5:46
Bracelet & strapmixed: Praises the easy-to-use T-fit clasp and its generous adjustment range. 2:51
Considers the faux rivets on the stepped bracelet over the top. 5:46
Thinks the watch looks and wears best on the five-link bracelet. 5:46
Dialmixed: Finds the lume very strong and long-lasting. 2:51
Loves the distinctive snowflake hour hand, finding it legible and preferring it to Mercedes hands. 4:18
Says anti-reflective coating is very poor, causing annoying reflections outdoors; nearly a deal breaker. 5:16
Functionalitypositive: Rates the bezel's tactile action best or near-best in its class. 2:51
Movementpositive: Enjoys the independently certified in-house movement and finds it robust. 3:19
Trusts it to keep consistent time through almost any activity. 3:49
Versatilitypositive: Considers it an excellent daily wear watch. 0:29
Finds the colour scheme versatile enough to work on any strap. 4:18
Designpositive: Finds the monochrome scheme attractive though safe and conservative. 0:00
Likes the retro feel from the aluminium insert, domed dial and stepped bracelet. 2:51
Compared with: Rolex Submariner: Submariner has more refined case proportions.
Rolex Submariner: Prefers Black Bay's snowflake hand over Submariner's Mercedes hand.
Omega Seamaster Professional: Black Bay feels less sleek and polished, more heritage-styled.
Tudor Black Bay Pro: Black Bay 41 is less chunky than the Black Bay Pro.

Watch on YouTube

Fratello

A Much-Desired Encounter With The Master Chronometer Tudor Black Bay “Monochrome”

ArticleHands-on reviewFeb 2025Jorg Weppelink

Very positiveRecommends

Calls the black Master Chronometer Black Bay a wonderful, clean, modern take on the classic Tudor Sub, praising its build, comfort and value under €5K. A personal wish for a more pronounced bezel and a pull toward the Pelagos keep it off the must-buy list.

Suits: Buyers wanting the best daily-wear modern dive watch under €5K

What the review says, point by point

Designpositive: Relieved Tudor chose a clean, modern execution rather than vintage styling.
Feels better than collection peers that use fake gold accents.
Admits it may look a bit boring, but sees that as the mark of a keeper.
Case & proportionspositive: Sees the optimized case dimensions as removing the chunkiness of other Tudor models.
Finds the 41mm size perfect on the wrist.
After a week, found the bezel not pronounced enough for personal taste.
Bracelet & strappositive: Considers the Oyster-style bracelet the right choice for this black version.
Quickly tired of the rubber strap version, citing a bracelet preference.
Screwed links made sizing easy.
The T-fit clasp closes with a satisfying, secure click.
Wearabilitypositive: Felt right on the wrist throughout days of wear.
Sits comfortably and naturally on the wrist.
Finishing & buildpositive: Feels more solid than most watches tested at a similar price.
No rattle anywhere thanks to precise tolerances.
Rates overall quality as outstanding.
Movementpositive: Views Master Chronometer certification as raising Tudor's movement standard.
Valuepositive: Considers it the best choice available at its price.
Cheaper than vintage Tudor Subs and a far better watch.
Versatilitypositive: Calls it the perfect pick for a daily wearer under €5K.
Originalitypositive: Sees it as the closest modern equivalent to a classic Tudor Submariner.
Notes its design follows the Rolex Submariner template.
Compared with: Tudor Black Bay Pro: Black Bay Pro remains the reviewer's favourite Tudor.
Tudor Black Bay 58 (black): Dislikes the BB58's faux-vintage looks; this 41mm is the Black Bay for them.
Tudor Submariner ref. 7016: Far cheaper than vintage Subs and a far better watch.
Rolex Sea-Dweller 16600: Wish for a bolder bezel and crown guards points toward the Sea-Dweller.

Read on fratellowatches.com

The Watch Idiot

The Tudor Black Bay 41 Monochrome AFTER The Hype: Is It Still Awesome? 4 Month Review

Video, 9 minOwner's reviewNov 2024

PositiveRecommends, with caveats

After four months, the reviewer praises the clean monochrome look, build quality, bezel action, T-fit clasp and anti-magnetic movement. However, it doesn't stand out in a collection full of black divers, and the five-link bracelet wore thin. It is being sold, mainly because of the Seamaster.

Suits: Those wanting a simple, well-built classic black diver, ideally on the three-link bracelet

Disclosure: Reviewer owns it

What they said, point by point

Designpositive: Values the complete absence of gilt or colour accents. 0:56
Sees it as the first modern Black Bay in the most classic colour combination. 1:25
Finds the simple case design appealing, though whether it suits depends on the wearer's taste. 1:54
Dialpositive: Likes the crisp white indices and lume. 1:25
Reducing the text to two lines makes the dial notably less cluttered. 1:54
Wearabilitymixed: The curved caseback teeth make it more comfortable than the BB58 and BB54. 2:22
The heavy head can feel top-heavy on the five-link bracelet, though this isn't a real problem. 2:51
Bracelet & strapmixed: Finds the bracelet silky, smooth, and excellent. 2:51
Considers the T-fit the best on-the-fly adjustment clasp, above Rolex's Glidelock. 3:19
The novelty of the five-link wore off, and a fully brushed three-link would suit it better. 8:10
The polished clasp centre picks up hairline scratches easily. 8:39
Finishing & buildpositive: Feels high quality in the hand and on the wrist. 2:22
Transitions between brushed and polished surfaces are sharp and consistent. 3:19
Functionalitypositive: Calls it the best 60-click bezel ever used: perfectly weighted with crisp clicks. 3:49
The chunkier bezel teeth make turning easier than on the BB58. 4:18
Movementpositive: Proven accurate in the reviewer's own testing. 4:47
Anti-magnetism is increasingly practical with magnets everywhere, giving peace of mind when travelling. 5:46
Originalitynegative: Lacks distinctiveness in a collection of similar divers, so it rarely got worn. 6:44
Still not considered boring, thanks to its classic design. 6:44
Compared with: Tudor Black Bay 54: Similar design, but the BB54 is more compelling due to unique size and details.
Tudor Black Bay 58: BB41's curved caseback teeth and chunkier bezel grip are more comfortable and easier to turn.
Tudor Black Bay 58 Blue: The blue dial isn't fully classic; the monochrome is the true classic modern take.
Omega Seamaster 300M Professional: Its arrival is the main reason the BB41 Monochrome is being sold.

Watch on YouTube

Monochrome

The New Tudor Black Bay Master Chronometer is a Classic Monochrome Diver

ArticleHands-on reviewMay 2024Brice Goulard

Very positiveRecommends

Calls the monochrome Black Bay Master Chronometer one of the best classic dive watches available. The reviewer praises its slimmer case, demanding certification and fair price. Admits the look may seem mundane or unoriginal to some but values its timelessness.

Suits: Buyers wanting a classic, timeless dive watch to wear for decades

What the review says, point by point

Case & proportionspositive: Sees the reduced thickness as fixing one of the model's main flaws.
Likes how thinner flanks and a domed caseback make the case look slimmer.
Notes it remains a large watch; suggests smaller siblings for those wanting compact.
Wearabilitypositive: Describes the wearing experience as pleasant.
Designpositive: Believes the design will still look purposeful for many years.
Undecided about the removal of the red bezel triangle, though it suits the monochrome concept.
Acknowledges some may see the looks as mundane or boring.
Sees the all-monochrome version as very different from the polarizing burgundy model.
Movementpositive: Highlights that the movement now carries one of the toughest certifications on the market.
Bracelet & strappositive: Finds the T-fit micro-adjustment clasp practical.
Sees the ceramic ball bearings in the clasp as a sign of commitment to durability.
Finishing & buildpositive: Credits Tudor with delivering superb quality.
Concedes it lacks the fine detailing and prestige of the Rolex Submariner.
Originalitymixed: Concedes it is probably not the most striking or original design.
Valuepositive: Considers the price fair given its quality and features, which is rare in the current market.
Sees it as more than just a cheaper Submariner alternative.
Compared with: Rolex Submariner 124060: Less refined and prestigious, but offers a lot at under half the price.

Read on monochrome-watches.com

Adrian Barker

Week on the Wrist - Tudor Black Bay 41 Monochrome 2024

Video, 9 minHands-on reviewMay 2024

PositiveRecommends

Finds the monochrome Black Bay somewhat characterless and unoriginal as a mere colour change without vintage touches. Still praises the bracelet, bezel action and METAS robustness, calling it an ideal daily, first or collection-anchor watch likely to sell massively.

Suits: First watch, daily wearer, or the foundation of a collection

What they said, point by point

Designmixed: Welcomes the overall refinement of the third-generation design. 1:17
Feels losing the gilt and red triangle removes some of the watch's character. 2:17
Calls it cold and clinical, possibly boring, but says boring is not a negative for them. 2:45
Expects the plain look to make it a huge seller for Tudor. 2:45
Originalitynegative: Considers it a generic black-bezel, black-dial diver among countless others. 0:49
Notes it is not really new, only a colour variation of last year's model. 0:49
Functionalitypositive: Praises the bezel action. 0:00
Bezel overhang is seen as useful for grip. 4:12
Sees METAS certification as meaning the watch can handle daily life without care. 7:31
Bracelet & strappositive: Calls the bracelet incredible and among the best from any brand. 4:12
Rates the T-fit clasp extension system as one of the best, and the clasp as good-looking. 4:41
In the intro, jokingly dismisses the riveted bracelet as horrible. 0:00
Prefers it on a textile strap, while acknowledging bias as a strap seller. 3:43
Case & proportionspositive: Measures the case as effectively 40mm rather than the stated 41mm. 4:12
Points out no crown guards but a large, substantial crown. 5:11
Explains the domed crystal lets the case itself be slightly slimmer. 5:11
Movementpositive: Notes the calibre is the same as before, merely tested by METAS. 6:07
Believes METAS proof of antimagnetism and temperature resilience has real worth. 7:03
Versatilitypositive: Calls it an ideal first and daily watch to build a collection around. 8:00
Suggests it could be a one-watch collection despite scepticism of the concept. 8:00
Compared with: Tudor Black Bay (second generation): New version is refined, slightly slimmer, with METAS certification on the same movement.

Watch on YouTube

Teddy Baldassarre

Tudor Released A Submariner, Well Kind Of... The New Black Bay 41mm (Hands-On Review)

Video, 11 minHands-on reviewMay 2024

PositiveRecommends, with caveats

Sees the monochrome Black Bay 41 as the closest Tudor has come to a modern Submariner. Praises its slimmer new proportions, Master Chronometer movement and T-fit clasp, while admitting the design is derivative and may polarise.

Suits: Tudor collectors who wanted a modern Tudor Submariner

What they said, point by point

Case & proportionspositive: Considers the redesigned grooved crown, echoed on the bezel edge, the standout change and easier to grip. 3:23
Notes the sizing approach differs greatly from the original 41mm Black Bay despite the same diameter. 2:25
Wearabilitypositive: Urges people to try it on, as it wears completely differently from earlier, larger-wearing 41mm Black Bays. 2:55
Believes the new fit could change which Black Bay suits a given wrist size. 2:55
Finishing & buildpositive: Says finishing details elevate the presentation and add modern aesthetics. 2:55
Points out a wider hairline facet separating the brushed top from polished sides. 3:23
Bracelet & strapmixed: Calls the T-fit tool-free micro-adjustment class-leading and easy to size. 4:21
Appreciates ceramic pins in the clasp to resist long-term wear. 3:52
Warns the polished centre of the clasp will scratch more easily than before. 3:52
Dialpositive: Notes the dial text is among the simplest in the collection. 4:50
Highlights the high contrast of the pure black and white execution. 4:50
Movementpositive: Considers the MT5602-U's specifications class-leading for its price point. 6:47
Credits the upgraded calibre as part of why the watch delivers for collectors. 9:41
Designpositive: Calls it the closest thing yet to a faithful Tudor Submariner revival. 8:42
Says it delivers exactly what many Tudor collectors wanted. 9:41
Originalitymixed: Says the world does not need another black-and-white Submariner-inspired diver. 9:11
Acknowledges that in isolation it reads as derivative. 9:11
Feels Tudor's shared claim to the Submariner design legitimises it. 9:11
Compared with: Tudor Black Bay 41 (earlier generation): New version is thinner and shorter, wearing completely differently.
Rolex Submariner: Design more directly emulates modern Submariners; derivative but justified.
Tudor Black Bay 41 Burgundy (2023): Laid the foundation; shares wearability, movement and sunbrushed dial.

Watch on YouTube

The Deep Track

Video Review: Tudor Black Bay 41 ‘Monochrome’ Charts a New Path - The Deep Track

ArticleHands-on reviewApr 2024Blake Buettner

Very positiveRecommends

Calls the monochrome Black Bay 41 a very, very good watch and a turning point for the collection. Praises its timeless, formal dial and versatility, with minor gripes about case height, a hard-to-grip bezel and a loose-feeling three-link bracelet.

Suits: Someone wanting a single dive watch to cover all bases under $5,000

What the review says, point by point

Designpositive: Believes the design suits the stark monochrome contrast perfectly.
Sees a formality in this watch not found elsewhere in the Black Bay collection.
Dialpositive: Finds the dial old-school in a timeless way.
Thinks dropping gilt lets the design choices be appreciated on their own terms.
Likes the new lollipop seconds hand as a nod to older references.
Case & proportionsmixed: Credits the 21mm lug width with creating a more natural flow into the bracelet.
Welcomes the polished chamfer along the lug edge as a transition.
Notes the case thickness remains very visible from the side.
Warns that the long lugs may overhang on some wrists.
Wearabilitypositive: Considers the new case perfectly wearable and pleasant on the wrist.
Finds it sits higher and feels more top heavy than a Submariner.
Says recent changes nudged the watch inside the reviewer's comfort zone.
Bracelet & strapmixed: Would likely recommend the five-link bracelet over the three-link.
Finds the female end link and connector articulate well but feel loose.
Sees the bracelet feel as the biggest in-hand sign of the price gap to a Submariner.
Notes the T-Fit clasp adjusts more softly than Rolex's Glidelock.
Functionalitymixed: Finds the thin, tight bezel edge difficult to grab and turn.
Considers it nearly as capable as the rivals it was compared against.
Versatilitypositive: Says it pairs equally well with a suit or casual clothes.
Notes collectors with many classic divers will find nothing new here.
Originalitypositive: Feels the watch marks a turning point for the collection.
Sees it as a modern preservation rather than a mere throwback.
Valuepositive: Doubts in-hand differences justify the Submariner's much higher price.
Cannot imagine a better single dive watch under $5,000.
Compared with: Rolex Submariner 114060: Sub's trimmer case wall nestles into the wrist better.
Rolex Submariner 124060: Similar selling points at under half the price; gap not justified.
Rolex Submariner 124060: Sub's bracelet feel and firmer clasp adjustment are clearly better.
Tudor Pelagos: Pelagos bezel edge is easier to grip and turn.
Tudor Black Bay 58: Black Bay 41 brings more heft on the wrist.

Read on thedeeptrack.com

aBlogtoWatch

Hands-On: The Colorless Tudor Black Bay Watch For 2024

ArticleFirst lookApr 2024Mike Razak

PositiveRecommends

A brief, upbeat hands-on that presents the monochrome Black Bay 41 as a simple line extension. The reviewer praises its sedate grey-scale look, excellent wrist presence, strap options and versatility, and prefers it to the Black Bay 58 and 54.

Suits: Those wanting an unfussy, sedate Black Bay without gilt or blue-black accents

What the review says, point by point

Designpositive: Sees the grey-scale colourway as an unfussy, sedate alternative to gilt or blue-black versions.
Considers removing colour potentially more impactful than adding a new one.
Enjoys the plain monochrome execution.
Wearabilitypositive: Says the 41mm Black Bay sits excellently on the wrist.
Prefers wearing it over the Black Bay 58 and 54.
Bracelet & strappositive: Calls the straps great and values the T-Fit adjustment for fitting any wrist.
Versatilitypositive: Believes the colourway pairs well with almost any aftermarket strap.
Suggests the lack of colour could make it the most versatile Black Bay yet.
Compared with: Tudor Black Bay 58: Reviewer prefers the 41mm Black Bay on the wrist.
Tudor Black Bay 54: Reviewer prefers the 41mm Black Bay on the wrist.

Read on ablogtowatch.com

Specifications

Reference: M7941A1A0NU-0001
Case: 41mm, stainless steel
Thickness: 13.6mm
Lug to lug: 50mm
Movement: Tudor Manufacture Calibre MT5602-U (Master Chronometer, COSC + METAS) (automatic)
Power reserve: 70 hours
Water resistance: 200m
Crystal: domed sapphire
Bracelet or strap: riveted three-link steel bracelet with T-fit clasp (also five-link bracelet -0003 or black rubber strap -0002)
Announced: April 2024
List price (US): $4,435US launch price $4,435 on the riveted three-link bracelet (-0001)

Creator Consensus is built only from what reviewers said. Prices, retailers and any commercial relationship never affect it. How consensus works